|
|
Post by QuillofMinerva on Nov 28, 2004 13:19:43 GMT -5
was she head girl?
*i tend to lean towards the idea that she was*
did she play quidditch? what position was she?
*i see her as a chaser*
|
|
|
|
Post by Lay on Nov 28, 2004 13:42:47 GMT -5
I think she was head girl and i see her more a seeker than a chaser
|
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 28, 2004 14:05:42 GMT -5
Hm, I would rather see her as some kind of early Weasley - the troublemaker of her time. *g* Would be fun. ;D But it's more likely that she was headgirl. And a seeker - a cat needs good eyes.  Hugs, Rikki |
|
|
|
Post by angeldust on Nov 28, 2004 14:06:18 GMT -5
Cheaser n captin  thougth head maybe yes but then again maybe no as she might have been a trouble maker Trouble maker = no Quite studier- Yes But in my opition she was a bit of both, ok im no help will shut up  |
|
|
|
Post by ginger newts on Nov 28, 2004 14:08:53 GMT -5
I think there's a good chance she was headgirl. I think she was probably a bit like Hermione in school, the way JKR is always comaring Hermione's reactions to Minerva now...then again she could have been the forerunner to the marauders and the Weasley twins. Who knows. As for Quidditch, no idea if she was a player or just a crazy fan. That's difficult to guess at.
|
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 28, 2004 14:16:41 GMT -5
I would tend to player - she just doesn't seem like a crazed fan to me. Anyway with that slender frame she would have made an excellent seeker. ;D
Hugs, Rikki
|
|
|
|
Post by Mellypoo622 on Nov 28, 2004 16:19:38 GMT -5
I think she was Head Girl, and maybe did play qudditch (Mayeb even captain). Not sure which posistion she would have played though. I think she knew how to haev fun but knew limits too. Like when it was time to stop having fun in order to get homework done and such.
|
|
|
|
Post by QuillofMinerva on Nov 28, 2004 16:44:18 GMT -5
well Chris Columbus and the script writers of ps/ss thought she must have played quidditch because her name is on the quidditch shield  |
|
|
|
Post by ginger newts on Nov 28, 2004 16:51:43 GMT -5
I've seen that. It says M.G. McGonagall, but it's dated 1975. That's way too late for it to be her, but I'm confused about it. I suppose it's possible they got the dates wrong, but could it be the suggestion of another McGonagall? I wonder if Ms. Rowling had anything to do with that or even noticed it... Sigh, if only she would tell us more about dear Minerva we wouldn't have to have so many questions.
|
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 28, 2004 16:52:14 GMT -5
Really? I didn't see that... *goes looking for her dvd*
Hugs, Rikki
|
|
|
|
Post by QuillofMinerva on Nov 28, 2004 17:54:55 GMT -5
Maybe its Albus and Minerva's daughter or son lol
~~~~~~~~~i can dream~~~~~~~~~~~~
i wish we knew more about Minerva too, i know JKR said in a interview that she has wriiten background information on all the chracters...giving them a full history so she knows them well....would love to get my hands on those notes
|
|
|
|
Post by ginger newts on Nov 28, 2004 17:58:47 GMT -5
That would be bloody fantastic! I would love to get my hands on her notes about Minerva and Albus myself. She's got to know a lot more about them than she's given us in the books. Here's hoping for more in the next book! |
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 29, 2004 3:58:48 GMT -5
Hm, I thought about Minnie's position in the quidditch team again. Even though I stated earlier that she might have been a seeker ... if she was on the same quidditch team as James Potter that's obviously not possible. But when the names on the shield are in order of the positions then she must have been a beater... Just a thought. Hugs, Rikki |
|
|
|
Post by ginger newts on Nov 29, 2004 11:24:12 GMT -5
Well, the thing is we can't go by that entirely because it's a movie prop. Also, according to canon she wouldn't have been in school with James Potter she would have been his teacher so they definitely weren't on the same team.
|
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 29, 2004 13:24:46 GMT -5
Yeah, I just remembered that too.  But nonetheless I'm convinced that she used to play quidditch. ;D Hugs, Rikki |
|
|
|
Post by QuillofMinerva on Nov 29, 2004 14:49:17 GMT -5
im convinced she was head girl but not so convinced about the quidditch
i wonder what the sorting hat said to her when she was sorted?
|
|
|
|
Post by TabbyForever on Nov 29, 2004 16:55:31 GMT -5
Ummm i reckon she was head girl and on the quiddtich team!!!
Prob either a chaser or seeker....not sure with.
As for the sheild....i know what you mean, on several occasions i've been watching the movie and just had to play that scene and zoom in on it to see....I really don't understand it!! JKR has i believe already stated that she taught the maurderes so i wanna know which M.G McGonagall it is!!! And its soooooo gotta be a son/daughter!!!
Awwww I just wanna know!!!!
J
BTW, i once did an x-ray on a McGonagall....however she spelt her name a bit different...just thought i'd share that!!hehehe
Bye for now
|
|
|
|
Post by Mellypoo622 on Nov 29, 2004 17:19:06 GMT -5
Since I have no idea how to quote just one sentence on this board...
BTW, i once did an x-ray on a McGonagall....however she spelt her name a bit different...just thought i'd share that!!hehehe
Bye for now
Theres a girl in my health glass and her name is Melissa with a name said like McGonagall just spelled different.. its so funyn because I'm Melissa too so when the teacher is like "Melissa McGonagall" I get all like "What did she just say?" LOL
|
|
|
|
Post by Rikki on Nov 30, 2004 2:28:12 GMT -5
Hehe, sounds really funny. *g*
|
|
thougth head maybe yes but then again maybe no as she might have been a trouble maker 
